Updating the "Granny Cart"

The trunk of the car(less), again.
This post is 17 in the series: Bicycle Neglect

hotrod granny cart_Flickr_uzbeckistanTransport guru Todd Litman says the biggest vehicular breakthrough of recent decades is the rolling suitcase. That’s not the conventional wisdom. Most recent attention to the wheels of the future focuses on electric cars, and they are clearly essential. Still, for some, they are also a false hope, suggesting that all we need to change is our drive trains, not our auto-centered way of life. If our future is to be sustainable, however, the role of cars—electric or otherwise—will have to diminish. The obesity epidemic, the range limits of electric batteries, the pressing need to get off the carbon-fuel rollercoaster as soon as possible, and other challenges suggest that changing vehicles’ power source is only part of the solution.

In the end, the real alternative to automobiles is not better automobiles. It is better neighborhoods. Complete, compact communities enable walking, cycling, and transit to thrive. They make electric vehicles’ limited range adequate. And they allow cars to fill their rightful place as one transportation tool among many, rather than as the organizing principle of daily life.

It’s in the context of better neighborhoods—dense, vibrant, beautiful, mixed-use, mixed-income, mixed-age communities—that rolling suitcases are a vehicular breakthrough. Well-wheeled luggage is a vast improvement on the lift-and-carry type, and it is actually just the beginning of the innovations in human-powered motion. This post on the wheels of the urban future launches a short series on the subject. My frequent collaborator Alyse Nelson, an urban planner, assembled the photos. The series expands on this pictorial ode.

Granny cart crossing_Flickr_Ed YourdonThe options for human-powered transport just keep proliferating, as tinkerers and entrepreneurs apply ingenuity and ball bearings to the task of moving people and their stuff around. Future posts will cover community carts, bike trailers, cargo bikes, and an array of wackier inventions. First, though, a pedestrian starter: updating the “granny cart.”

The traditional personal shopping cart is a collapsible, wire-grid cage with two or four wheels. It’s as utilitarian an option as it was for my car-less grandmother in the 1960s. Better models easily support more than 100 pounds, and if you don’t like the styling, you can trick yours out, as Instructables.com details (and pictured atop this post).

Newer designs include this more-maneuverable canvas cart, which collapses like an umbrella.

These trusty carts, however, are rapidly giving ground to better-engineered and more-expensive models, some smaller and others bigger and many of them documented at Cities21.

Versacart - umbrella folding cart_Versacart website

 

Stairclimber cart_roadrunner website

Among the smaller models are several scaled like wheeled luggage, carrying just one or two sacks of groceries. This one (at left) by Roadrunner has a three-wheeled design that allows it to climb stairs.

The even smaller Foldable Trolley (at right) by Reisenthel folds up—wheels and all—inside its own handbag-sized pocket.

Reisenthel - foldable cart folded and open_flickr_framboise
reisenthal carrycruiser cart_reisenthal website

This stylish model (at left) also impersonates a shoulder tote when folded, but has a telescoping handle to operate like wheeled luggage.  Thoughtful design makes it versatile.


The manufacturer Rosler, meanwhile, offers a vast array of European-made (and styled) carts
in bright colors, some sturdier, some more easily folded. This one, for example, folds and hangs from a grocery’s shopping cart while you’re in the store. A UK competitor—the Typhoon Spotty Trolley (at right)—is insulated to keep your groceries cool.
Typhoon Spotty Cart_Lakeland website
Hook and Go in action cropped_Cities21

A minimalist design from California (at left) is a rolling hanger for shopping bags. Its lack of a carrying basket of its own makes it easier to fold and, therefore, to stow while shopping.

Folding hand trucks such as this one and this one can haul the heaviest loads.

Mobile folding file cart_Office Depot

The best built carts, in my view, are baby strollers with cargo capacity (and convertible bike trailers, which I’ll discuss another time). They cost hundreds of dollars, and that’s a lot of money compared to a granny cart. On the other hand, it’s peanuts compared to a car.

The photo below shows Alyse Nelson touring Europe with her baby and her fully-loaded stroller, plus a wheeled suitcase . . .

Loaded stroller_Alyse Nelson

and here is a look at the cargo capacity of her stroller.

Stroller capacity_Alyse Neslon

Big-wheeled jogging strollers such as this one have more capacity and easier handling than the standard type pictured above. Some can even accommodate panniers, for added storage. But they also cost more and take up more space.

In time, as cities grow increasingly walkable and more people want to do their errands on foot, I expect that personal carts and baby strollers will essentially merge, with interchangeable fittings and modular components for kids and groceries. (They will also merge with bike trailers, as I’ll argue another time.) Communities that are eager to promote walking will also find ways to accommodate them: providing easy, secure parking in shops and cafés, and welcoming them on buses and trains. At present, as Alyse points out, you can’t bring a cart or stroller on a bus in the Northwest without emptying it and folding it up first. In Denmark, in contrast, strollers have a place on transit, just like wheel chairs.

Next time: community cart programs.

Huge thanks to Alyse Nelson for researching this post!

Photo Credits:
Hotrod Granny Cart photo courtesy of Flickr uzbeckistan.
Photo of carts crossing the street courtesy of Flickr user Ed Yourdon under Creative Commons licensing.
Reisenthel CarryCruiser photos from Flickr user framboise under Creative Commons licensing.
Hook and Go photo courtesy of Cities21
Photos of Alyse Nelson and kid/cargo carrying stroller courtesy of Alyse Nelson. 

 

 

We are a community-supported resource and we can’t do this work without you!

Comments

  1. buster G. says:

    Whatever happened to the even more maneuverable backpack for many of these purposes?

  2. Alan Durning says:

    Buster G.,Do you think I should write a blog post about the backpack? The messenger bag? Perhaps the purse? Maybe a post on pockets and shopping bags? The opposable thumb?Backpacks are great. I focused on wheeled devices, because they are more likely to substitute for car trips on which you have a load too heavy to comfortably carry yourself.Alan

  3. j argasinski says:

    I live that European style!

  4. ssw says:

    I worked on a project with Feet First a few years back to distribute some classier carts to people who lived near grocery stores. It was just a pilot study, but had a positive impact of more local residents choosing to walk to the store. People seemed happy to walk with the cart if they could carry enough to make their trip feel worthwhile and that they didn’t feel embarrassed toting it. Talking to participants, time and again people told me that cart use is really common in many other U.S. cities, and the northwest has just missed the train.

  5. Alan Durning says:

    Thanks, SSW.My next post, which we’ll probably publish next week, mentions the Feet First pilot. It’s good to hear your experiences.

  6. Yuri Artibise says:

    When my wife and i lived (car free) in a urban townhouse a few blocks away from several grocery stores, we used our ‘granny cart’ all the time. We found it far better than our backbacks for carrying heavy items like milk, bags of flour, etc. It’s great to see that both form and function have improved considerably. Hopefully this will increase their use and decrease the amont of trips people feel they need to take by car.

  7. brett says:

    Sturdy wheeled luggage—the kind that’s meant to traverse streets and not just airports—makes it easier to use public transportation for travel. For example, in Portland, I take the Max light rail train to the airport ($2 or so) and when I return, I can walk home with my suitcase rolling along with me. So no need to drive or take a taxi. (If I lived farther away from a Max stop, I could take the bus.) When traveling in Europe last summer, I did the same thing, hauling my suitcase in Spain and France so I wouldn’t need to rent a car or take a taxi.

  8. Sheilagh says:

    Alan,Nice article! Great to see that some of the designs on the granny cart are getting improvement. I had a granny cart and used it however it had two flaws (one proving fatal) 1) the handle was too short and not comfortable even for our short walk to the store, maybe ten blocks each direction and 2) it could not handle much weight, it collapsed on a halloween canned food drive that our kids participated in and that was then end of it… We usually walk and carry bags and limit our purchases, ride a bike and fill a backpack and or panniers (and still watch the amount purchasing) or drive our electric car and use reusable bags… great article, thanks!

  9. Georgie Kunkel says:

    “granny” is a name that is agist. Not all grannies lose muscle power and not all those older people owho do lose muscle power are grandparents. Granny is a sterotype. I know, I acted in threeCredit Card Revolt videos as a “granny” but I am a real granny.I have nine grandchildren and nine great grandchildren.It is difficult not to stereotype people in our society.This is a minor infringement.Cheers, Georgie

    • Betty says:

      I agree with this. Since I’ve gotten older I am amazed at judgements about the elderly. On Facebook if people want to insult someone they use “old” as an insult like they’re not on the same path and have no relatives they love who’ve aged. I’m proud to say that only once (many years ago) have I disparaged the aged and my father cured me when he said “You’ll be old too someday if you live long enough.”
      And by the way, I’ve seen many more younger people than older using these carts. The young/disabled who can’t afford cars use them frequently to transport groceries/items from the neighborhood stores. So maybe you should call them poverty carts.

  10. PN says:

    Go to quirky.com—they are working on just such an updated cart now!

  11. Rachel Gidwani says:

    Excellent site. A lot of helpful information here. I’m sending it to some friends ans additionally sharing in delicious. And naturally, thank you for your sweat!

  12. Paul says:

    Do you guys bring the cart into the store, or leave it outside and then load the groceries into your own cart? What are the mechanics of using it?

  13. emma says:

    A very good article about the folding shopping cart. Keep up the good work

  14. Betty says:

    I’ve been looking for the ideal cart to get my groceries in the house in one trip for years. I have had many and stopped using them for various reasons, boiling down to they were more trouble than they’re worth. One problem is that groceries get squashed if they are stacked up so you have to plan how they go in which takes a lot of time in the rain, for example. Another is that once you get them in the house, they have to be somewhere which means more clutter for the elderly who already have a problem with that. You could take the empty cart back to the car in the rain or leave it sitting by the front door so you won’t forget it next time, which is a nuisance. If you store it back in the car you have to listen to it rattle or slide while you drive to places besides the grocery store and there it is when you want to use the space in the cargo area for something else. If you put groceries in the cart while it’s in the back of your SUV then it’s too heavy to lift to the ground. It just seems like there is no easy and practical way to avoid the strain and inconvenience of handling the physical aspects of grocery shopping. What I’m doing right now is taking in the things that need to be in cold storage and the things I need that day, then taking my time getting the rest. I have not tried the wagon type yet but it seems to me that it might be the better design since groceries could be spread out more avoiding pressure on delicate items and would also be easier to sort when putting them up. As for the idea that cars are something we are going to have to use less in the future you had better convince auto makers that we won’t pay $30,000 for an occasional ride.

  15. Shawn says:

    Thank you very much for writing this article. Saves me lots of time from having to research rolling carts on my own. I take the bus and am thinking of getting the Roadrunner 3-wheeler. The one that hangs bags look cool too, but I wonder how itd hold up to 10 min walks to my apt. Might break or get heavy. Thanks again! I love finding sites like yours that point me at exactly the info I’m looking for.

  16. Shawn says:

    Looks like I won’t be getting the Roadrunner or Hook n Go afterall. Reviews say Roadrunner falls apart, and Hook n Go bends under weight. Plus both have lousy wheels. Inline skate wheels are sounding the best, but the only one I’ve found is Western Pack, and it’s currently out of stock. Do you know of any really good, sturdy, long-lasting rolling shopping bags that are decently slim for aisles of bus?

Leave a Comment

Please keep it civil and constructive. Our editors reserve the right to monitor inappropriate comments and personal attacks.

*

You may add a link with HTML: <a href="URL">text to display</a>